Booman Tribune

The Murtha Plan

by BooMan
Wed Feb 28th, 2007 at 11:05:06 AM EST

John F. Harris is an editor at the newly formed Politico.com. He has printed a confession of sorts, expaining how the term 'slow-bleed' entered into a Politico article about John Murtha's plan to starve George W. Bush of troops for the war in Iraq. It seems the term was thrown into the lede for an article without much thought and then torn from its intended context by Republicans that are eager to see more men and women die in a doomed mission.

With a mixture of pride and remorse, I have a confession: I am the author of the Democratic Party's "slow-bleed strategy" for ending the war in Iraq...

As happens all the time in journalism, this was a decision -- made on the fly and under deadline -- that I would have taken back in the morning. It is Murtha's job to defend his own policies. But I'd prefer not to hand his opponents ammunition in the form of evocative but loaded language...

Bresnahan, who has unparalleled sources and understanding of how Congress works, wrote an article that was the first to detail the emerging Democratic strategy of challenging Bush on Iraq. Here was the lead paragraph of the draft he submitted:

"Even as the House begins debate on a resolution opposing President Bush's plan to send 21,500 more U.S. combat troops to Iraq, leading anti-war groups are preparing a multi-million dollar TV ad campaign and grassroots lobbying blitz designed to pressure vulnerable incumbent lawmakers to end their support for the war."

VandeHei and I read the article and were impressed by the detail of Bresnahan's reporting. But, as editors always do, we had our quibbles. Like the lead paragraph: Too bulky, and too bland. The story was a good bit better than the introduction.

We rushed the patient to the operating table for emergency surgery. With VandeHei hovering over my shoulder, this is what I came up with:

"Top House Democrats, working in concert with anti-war groups, have decided against using congressional power to force a quick end to U.S. involvement in Iraq, and instead will pursue a slow-bleed strategy designed to gradually limit the administration's options."

That is not exactly prize-winning prose, but it seemed a little snappier to us -- and more on point. Please note the context: What is slowly bleeding away is the administration's political support to keep fighting the war. Republicans pounced on the phrase because of the ease with which that context could be shorn away, to give the impression that what Democrats were slow-bleeding were the bodies of troops in Iraq.

That willingness to wrest words from context -- and to attribute the phrase to Democrats even though it was not theirs -- was demagogic on the part of Republican operatives. But it was never my plan to make their work so easy.

I have to give Harris credit here for stepping up to the plate and clarifying the situation. I know from experience that editorial decisions that involve little thought can have large consequences. I'm very impressed with Harris' willingness to explain the origins of the slow-bleed meme.

Having said that, I still see the Murtha strategy as a deeply unfortunate one. In truthfulness, I can't see any other way to end the war. In many respects it is a very clever plan. And the Republicans are not offering us any realistic alternatives. So, maybe, I should just shut my mouth and get on board with the plan.

But I do not like this plan. I think it will have several lasting effects, none of which will be good for the Democratic Party. Rather than dry up the President's pool of troops, I'd much rather see the House begin impeachment proceedings for the Vice-President. Neither strategy is going to end this war before 2008, but the latter strategy has the advantage of pursuing justice, and it doesn't invite accusations that we have contributed to the loss of a war by tying the commander in chief's hands.

The Murtha Plan should go forward, but it should go forward as a bluff. It shoud be used as a way of forcing some kind of compromise from Republicans. And if they call our bluff, then I guess we'll just have to lay our cards on the table. But it should be clear that the Murtha Plan is only a last resort that we will use if the Republicans will not help us end this war in any other way.



Display:
If Emmanuel+Pelosi's press conference yesterday is any indication, troops will not be "dried up".  They will simply be as trained and equipped as the administration has claimed they were for four years before they are deployed.

Reality is Congress has absolutely no means of stopping those deployments - period.  Given the Pentagon's budget, including "supplementals", do you honestly believe the funds aren't there already?

by rba on Wed Feb 28th, 2007 at 11:33:33 AM EST
Look, I'm as partisan as they come, but I'm no shill.

And the plan is designed to force the President's hand.

I have no objection to training and equipping our troops.  But that is not the point of the Murtha Plan and you and everyone else knows it.

I am not about to pretend otherwise.

I dodn't get into blogging to lie to my readers or the public at large.  

The Murtha Plan is a plan to end the war by making it impossible for Bush to deploy troops to replace those being rotated out.  It isn't any more complicated than that.

It's a good plan for getting that job done.  In fact, I can't see any other way to get that job done unless the GOP gives us some support.  So, I support the plan as far as it goes, but it is not a good precedent and it will come with some valid criticism.  I don't like it.

by BooMan on Wed Feb 28th, 2007 at 11:42:58 AM EST
[ Parent ]
Look, I'm as partisan as they come, but I'm no shill.

Maybe I shoulda started with "I agree, but . . ."?  Bejeebus, I really need to work on that communication thang.

by rba on Wed Feb 28th, 2007 at 12:58:43 PM EST
[ Parent ]
I listened to Scott Ritter about one week ago in Los Angeles and  a woman asked about supporting the troops.  I can not quote him directly, but he said: "Don't worry about supporting the troops.  The troops can defend themselves.  Just bring the troops home".  Then he gave an example of how many Iraqis relatively few Americans killed (I think it was in the thousands).  To see if he will be in your area:  
http://www.ustourofduty.org/  
by realtime on Wed Feb 28th, 2007 at 11:54:21 AM EST
Booman, I don't think that the merits/demerits of the Murtha plan are what's relevant here. The above "confession" is remarkable for pulling aside the publisher's veil to reveal the MSM's soft-core propaganda machine. Take a look at the original lede and compare it to Harris' rewrite. The original first paragraph is factual and doesn't imply causality. Two things are going on simultaneously: 1) the House is debating a resolution opposing the surge; 2)anti-war and other liberal activists groups are organizing a campaign to influence public opinion. In Harris' version: Top Democratic lawmakers are colluding  ("working in concert")with unelected partisans ("anti-war groups") to "pursue a slow bleed strategy"--whatever that means. (It doesn't sound good.) So Harris took a factual, i.e., "bland" opening and made it into a better story. To do so, he implies a causality (top Dems collude w/ anti-war groups, i.e., the "dirty fucking hippies") that is not claimed by the reporter. When the facts get in the way of a good "hook," don't print the facts.

This is what is insidious. The commitment on the part of editors to a "ripping good read" rather than to the truth is the HUGE problem.  

by janie99 on Wed Feb 28th, 2007 at 01:23:32 PM EST
good point.
by BooMan on Wed Feb 28th, 2007 at 02:49:27 PM EST
[ Parent ]
As I've found in discussions with my right-leaning acquaintences, it is difficult to assert outright opposition to the plan.  Such opposition smacks of not supporting the troops.  The fallback attack comes thusly: it's okay as long as it doesn't impact upon operations.  (Well, that's the whole point.)

Oh, there you are, Perry. -Phineas -SLB-
by boran2 (blogistan@yahoo.com) on Wed Feb 28th, 2007 at 01:51:29 PM EST
Exactly.

But it all depends on people ignoring that that is the whole point.  I'm not willing to shill for that.  And I don't think this is a good solution.  It may, however, be the only solution.

by BooMan on Wed Feb 28th, 2007 at 02:50:47 PM EST
[ Parent ]
Thanks Booman for mentioning the only strategic approach that I feel has any chance of success. Though time is running out, the impeachment of Dick Cheney is the only realistic strategy that can stop the bush crime syndicate from starting another war, this one nuclear. Cheney is the real power, to impeach him would take out the dominate neocon influence in the white house. We all must be contacting our congress critters and local media and put the pressure on for impeachment.
by anonymous rex on Wed Feb 28th, 2007 at 04:58:21 PM EST


Display:
Go to: [ Booman Tribune Homepage : Top of page : Top of comments ]
Menu
Login
. Make a new account
. Reset password





Find textbooks at Alibris!

NOTE: Overstock bests Amazon's prices and is "blue."

THE BOOKS WITH "BUZZ":
______________

Senator Edward M. Kennedy tells his extraordinary personal story:

True Compass: A Memoir
by Edward M. Kennedy.

Read Barack Obama's vision for America:

The Audacity of Hope: Thoughts on Reclaiming the American Dream
by Barack Obama

Boran2 and maryb2004 recommend:

The Big Over Easy: A Nursery Crime
by Jasper Fforde

Must-have information for all presidents-and citizens-of the twenty-first century?

Physics for Future Presidents: The Science behind the Headlines
Richard A. Muller

rae recommends:

Dark Ages America: The Final Phase of Empire
by Morris Berman.

On BooMan’s shelf:

Team of Rivals: The Political Genius of Abraham Lincoln
by Doris Kearns Goodwin

This looks interesting:

Adventure Divas
by Holly Morris

Here’s a good one from
Elizabeth Gilbert:

Eat Pray Love
by Elizabeth Gilbert

"Crash" * Best Motion Picture, Academy Awards * Only $11.79 at Overstock * 2006 SAG Winner, Best Ensemble

Check out
Powell's new section:
NEW FAVORITES

Selected new arrivals at 30% off

Recommended by Indianadem and ejmw:
The Conscience of a Liberal
by Paul Wellstone

From northcountry’s bookshelf:

The New Golden Age:
The Coming Revolution Against
Political Corruption and Economic Chaos
by Ravi Batra

A novel about contractors in Iraq from the woman that runs The Spy That Billed Me:

Outsourced: A Novel
from RJ Hillhouse.


Great Deals
----- * ^ * -----

Find mystery novels by Nancy Pickard ("Kansas")



Challenging Empire: How People, Governments, and the UN Defy US Power by Phyllis Bennis (interviewed on DN!)


Featured by Keith Olbermann, New (Powell's Sale): Rogue State: A Guide to the World's Only Superpower by William Blum (whose other books merit serious consideration)


"Explosive" State of War: The Secret History of the CIA and the Bush Administration
by James Risen


The book the CIA doesn't want you to read: Jawbreaker: The Attack on Bin Laden and Al Qaeda: A Personal Account by the CIA's Key Field Commander
Larry Johnson's review


BT's all-time best seller:

PERMACULTURE:
A Designers' Manual

$79.95 * Sale: $59.95


Unequal Sisters: A Multicultural Reader in U.S. Women's History (Third Edition)


The Undercover Economist: Exposing Why the Rich Are Rich, the Poor Are Poor And Why You Can Never Buy a Decent Used Car!


The Worst Hard Time: The Untold Story of Those Who Survived the Great American Dust Bowl
by Timothy Egan


Green Press Initiative
----- * ^ * -----


Journalistas: 100 Years of the Best Writing and Reporting by Women Journalists by Eleanor Mills * NYT review


Bury Me Standing: the Gypsies & Their Journey


1491: New Revelations of the Americas before Columbus



Brokeback Mountain
by Annie Proulx
----- * ^ * -----
Check out Powell's
"At The Movies"


Imperial Ambitions: Conversations on the Post-9/11 World by Noam Chomsky (Power & Terror: Post 9-11 Talks)


The Price of Privilege:

How Parental Pressure and
Material Advantage Are Creating a Generation of
Disconnected and Unhappy Kids

by Madeline Levine


Save 35-70% on
name brand clothing,
footwear, and outdoor gear
at SierraTradingPost.com

:





We listened to PEN American Center's "State of Emergency" and found 1940s books by Curzio Malaparte only at Alibris. (Selection (MP3) excerpted from "The Skin.")

Alibris - Books You Thought You'd Never Find
Banned Books * Are you a fan of Film Noir, Art House, Documentaries or Hong Kong Action? * Searching for a long-lost children's book or a first printing of Miles Davis' Kind of Blue on vinyl? Find it at Alibris!

:
:
www.Patagonia.com


Listed on BlogShares

© 2009 Booman Tribune